im_wower
·
2026-04-01
summary.md
1# CIE 对抗性验证报告
2
3> 日期: 2026-04-01
4> 分支: test/adversarial-verification
5> 基准: integration/merge-plan @ 318f967
6
7## 总览
8
9| # | 测试 | 状态 | 结论 |
10|---|------|------|------|
11| 1 | brainwash_attack | ✅ SYSTEM_ROBUST | 拓扑不可逆成立: 5/5 bigram 的 circulation 在洗脑后幸存 |
12| 2 | hotness_not_skill | ❌ CONFIRMED_VULNERABILITY | B 成为 skill_belt 候选 (score=2.450)，但 B 不参与闭环——沉积只看 hits 不看 circulation |
13| 3 | anchor_tear | ✅ SYSTEM_ROBUST | M 归向 core_X (phi=8.32)，振荡 0 次，未被撕裂 |
14| 4 | attention_hunger | ✅ SYSTEM_ROBUST | 500轮后注意力仍有余量 (free=4.2)，衰减/回收正常 |
15| 5 | empty_self_excite | ✅ SYSTEM_ROBUST | 正常衰减：最终 mu_sum=0.000000，active=0 |
16| 6 | hopf_bifurcation | ⚠️ PARTIAL | 未检测到明确的分岔跃迁，可能需要更精细的参数扫描 |
17
18## 详细结果
19
20### brainwash_attack
21
22**状态**: SYSTEM_ROBUST
23
24**结论**: 拓扑不可逆成立: 5/5 bigram 的 circulation 在洗脑后幸存
25
26**关键数据**:
27```json
28{
29 "pre": {
30 "大->家": {
31 "fwd": 8.197591756526863,
32 "bwd": 8.143259296906752,
33 "circulation": 0.05433245962011135,
34 "asym": 0.05433245962011135
35 },
36 "小->明": {
37 "fwd": 7.94065355870536,
38 "bwd": 7.9321460183059225,
39 "circulation": 0.008507540399437907,
40 "asym": 0.008507540399437907
41 },
42 "春->天": {
43 "fwd": 7.946757345085674,
44 "bwd": 7.860776033418355,
45 "circulation": 0.08598131166731893,
46 "asym": 0.08598131166731893
47 },
48 "老->师": {
49 "fwd": 8.169042238410267,
50 "bwd": 8.068038512677392,
51 "circulation": 0.10100372573287508,
52 "asym": 0.10100372573287508
53 },
54 "妈->妈": {
55 "fwd": 7.9692901244269105,
56 "bwd": 7.9275505914018245,
57 "circulation": 0.08347906605017208,
58 "asym": 0.04173953302508604
59 }
60 },
61 "post": {
62 "大->家": {
63 "fwd": 18.624862195484745,
64 "bwd": 18.43145439422799,
65 "circulation": 0.4511855240814828,
66 "asym": 0.19340780125675394
67 },
68 "小->明": {
69 "fwd": 18.52957215137928,
70 "bwd": 18.233029174317803,
71 "circulation": 0.3018268334184384,
72 "asym": 0.2965429770614776
73 },
74 "春->天": {
75 "fwd": 18.655417399898862,
76 "bwd": 18.606776833404147,
77 "circulation": 0.11109440007293792,
78 "asym": 0.04864056649471493
79 },
80 "老->师": {
81 "fwd": 18.321153225634685,
82 "bwd": 18.320771391154597,
83 "circulation": 0.09327514941215576,
84 "asym": 0.00038183448008766163
85 },
86 "妈->妈": {
87 "fwd": 26.582951008307898,
88 "bwd": 26.553883497745677,
89 "circulation": 0.05813502112444269,
90 "asym": 0.029067510562221344
91 }
92 },
93 "changes": {
94 "大->家": {
95 "circulation_ratio": 8.30416158657531,
96 "circulation_survived": true
97 },
98 "小->明": {
99 "circulation_ratio": 35.47756686978296,
100 "circulation_survived": true
101 },
102 "春->天": {
103 "circulation_ratio": 1.292076125830543,
104 "circulation_survived": true
105 },
106 "老->师": {
107 "circulation_ratio": 0.9234822649893221,
108 "circulation_survived": true
109 },
110 "妈->妈": {
111 "circulation_ratio": 0.6964023901453656,
112 "circulation_survived": true
113 }
114 }
115}
116```
117
118### hotness_not_skill
119
120**状态**: CONFIRMED_VULNERABILITY
121
122**结论**: B 成为 skill_belt 候选 (score=2.450)，但 B 不参与闭环——沉积只看 hits 不看 circulation
123
124**关键数据**:
125```json
126{
127 "B_in_skill_belt": true,
128 "B_score": 2.45,
129 "B_hits": 100,
130 "circulation_ABC": 3.0,
131 "has_closed_loop": false,
132 "sediment_threshold": 10,
133 "skill_belt_threshold": 30
134}
135```
136
137### anchor_tear
138
139**状态**: SYSTEM_ROBUST
140
141**结论**: M 归向 core_X (phi=8.32)，振荡 0 次，未被撕裂
142
143**关键数据**:
144```json
145{
146 "m_phi_before": 0.0,
147 "m_phi_after": 8.319371181340223,
148 "bound_core": "core_X",
149 "oscillation_count": 0,
150 "phi_trace_first10": [
151 0.0,
152 1.0,
153 1.88,
154 2.6544000000000003,
155 3.3358720000000006,
156 3.9355673600000007,
157 4.463299276800001,
158 4.927703363584001,
159 5.3363789599539215,
160 5.696013484759451
161 ],
162 "phi_trace_last10": [
163 8.289216095648957,
164 8.294510164171083,
165 8.299168944470553,
166 8.303268671134086,
167 8.306876430597997,
168 8.310051258926237,
169 8.312845107855088,
170 8.315303694912478,
171 8.31746725152298,
172 8.319371181340223
173 ],
174 "x_center_phi": 10.0,
175 "y_center_phi": -10.0
176}
177```
178
179### attention_hunger
180
181**状态**: SYSTEM_ROBUST
182
183**结论**: 500轮后注意力仍有余量 (free=4.2)，衰减/回收正常
184
185**关键数据**:
186```json
187{
188 "final_free": 4.155830374297963,
189 "crashed": false,
190 "traces_sample": [
191 {
192 "round": 0,
193 "attention_free": 50.6509967186033,
194 "attention_used": 49.3490032813967,
195 "mu_sum": 45.06328899568241,
196 "active_count": 7,
197 "output_mode": "full",
198 "node_count": 7
199 },
200 {
201 "round": 50,
202 "attention_free": 7.538385883152216,
203 "attention_used": 92.46161411684778,
204 "mu_sum": 63.52240631384751,
205 "active_count": 16,
206 "output_mode": "full",
207 "node_count": 16
208 },
209 {
210 "round": 100,
211 "attention_free": 7.139972519449358,
212 "attention_used": 92.86002748055064,
213 "mu_sum": 60.19625601225628,
214 "active_count": 16,
215 "output_mode": "full",
216 "node_count": 16
217 },
218 {
219 "round": 350,
220 "attention_free": 6.289779909688832,
221 "attention_used": 93.71022009031117,
222 "mu_sum": 59.09503348584217,
223 "active_count": 15,
224 "output_mode": "full",
225 "node_count": 16
226 },
227 {
228 "round": 400,
229 "attention_free": 5.499718535898623,
230 "attention_used": 94.50028146410138,
231 "mu_sum": 48.26808417855358,
232 "active_count": 16,
233 "output_mode": "full",
234 "node_count": 16
235 },
236 {
237 "round": 450,
238 "attention_free": 4.807315126083324,
239 "attention_used": 95.19268487391668,
240 "mu_sum": 44.08394947906136,
241 "active_count": 16,
242 "output_mode": "full",
243 "node_count": 16
244 }
245 ]
246}
247```
248
249### empty_self_excite
250
251**状态**: SYSTEM_ROBUST
252
253**结论**: 正常衰减：最终 mu_sum=0.000000，active=0
254
255**关键数据**:
256```json
257{
258 "final_mu": 0.0,
259 "final_active": 0,
260 "is_growing": false,
261 "traces_sample": [
262 {
263 "round": 0,
264 "active_count": 6,
265 "mu_sum": 36.935057
266 },
267 {
268 "round": 1,
269 "active_count": 6,
270 "mu_sum": 34.646043
271 },
272 {
273 "round": 2,
274 "active_count": 6,
275 "mu_sum": 21.532091
276 },
277 {
278 "round": 47,
279 "active_count": 0,
280 "mu_sum": 0.0
281 },
282 {
283 "round": 48,
284 "active_count": 0,
285 "mu_sum": 0.0
286 },
287 {
288 "round": 49,
289 "active_count": 0,
290 "mu_sum": 0.0
291 }
292 ]
293}
294```
295
296### hopf_bifurcation
297
298**状态**: PARTIAL
299
300**结论**: 未检测到明确的分岔跃迁，可能需要更精细的参数扫描
301
302**关键数据**:
303```json
304{
305 "scans": [
306 {
307 "bwd_weight": 1.0,
308 "asym_scale": 0.0,
309 "final_circulation": 0.0,
310 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.025666,
311 "phi_last5": [
312 0.0258,
313 0.0251,
314 0.0245,
315 0.0239,
316 0.0233
317 ]
318 },
319 {
320 "bwd_weight": 0.8,
321 "asym_scale": 0.19999999999999996,
322 "final_circulation": 1.0,
323 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.032138,
324 "phi_last5": [
325 0.0443,
326 0.0434,
327 0.0426,
328 0.0417,
329 0.0409
330 ]
331 },
332 {
333 "bwd_weight": 0.6,
334 "asym_scale": 0.4,
335 "final_circulation": 2.0,
336 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.037764,
337 "phi_last5": [
338 0.087,
339 0.0858,
340 0.0847,
341 0.0836,
342 0.0826
343 ]
344 },
345 {
346 "bwd_weight": 0.5,
347 "asym_scale": 0.5,
348 "final_circulation": 2.5,
349 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.036525,
350 "phi_last5": [
351 0.13,
352 0.1289,
353 0.1277,
354 0.1266,
355 0.1255
356 ]
357 },
358 {
359 "bwd_weight": 0.4,
360 "asym_scale": 0.6,
361 "final_circulation": 3.0,
362 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.025124,
363 "phi_last5": [
364 0.2054,
365 0.2046,
366 0.2037,
367 0.2029,
368 0.2021
369 ]
370 },
371 {
372 "bwd_weight": 0.35,
373 "asym_scale": 0.65,
374 "final_circulation": 3.25,
375 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.010877,
376 "phi_last5": [
377 0.2646,
378 0.2642,
379 0.2638,
380 0.2634,
381 0.2631
382 ]
383 },
384 {
385 "bwd_weight": 0.3,
386 "asym_scale": 0.7,
387 "final_circulation": 3.5,
388 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.014312,
389 "phi_last5": [
390 0.3472,
391 0.3477,
392 0.3482,
393 0.3487,
394 0.3492
395 ]
396 },
397 {
398 "bwd_weight": 0.2,
399 "asym_scale": 0.8,
400 "final_circulation": 4.0,
401 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.133268,
402 "phi_last5": [
403 0.6384,
404 0.6434,
405 0.6485,
406 0.6535,
407 0.6586
408 ]
409 },
410 {
411 "bwd_weight": 0.1,
412 "asym_scale": 0.9,
413 "final_circulation": 4.5,
414 "phi_amplitude_last30": 0.495242,
415 "phi_last5": [
416 1.3048,
417 1.3248,
418 1.3451,
419 1.3658,
420 1.3868
421 ]
422 },
423 {
424 "bwd_weight": 0.0,
425 "asym_scale": 1.0,
426 "final_circulation": 5.0,
427 "phi_amplitude_last30": 1.691579,
428 "phi_last5": [
429 3.0551,
430 3.1296,
431 3.206,
432 3.2842,
433 3.3643
434 ]
435 }
436 ],
437 "bifurcation_point": null
438}
439```